Nomy Arpaly Quotes

• Characters in Hollywood movies encounter a lot of car chases. Characters in novels rarely wash their hands or do their laundry. And in the work of moral psychologists, people deliberate and reflect a lot. They deliberate, one sometimes feels, whenever they perform an action, and certainly whenever they act for good reasons.

  Nomy Arpaly

  Character, People, Car

  Nomy Arpaly (2002). “Unprincipled Virtue: An Inquiry Into Moral Agency”, p.20, Oxford University Press

  4 Copy quote

• Other things being equal, ill will is worse than moral indifference (as in causing suffering for money vs causing suffering to cause suffering), though things are rarely equal.

  Nomy Arpaly

  Suffering, Moral, Indifference

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  9 Copy quote

• If I make a stupid decision but don't execute it because I'm, say, lazy, then I'm lucky, not rational. However, at other times a person acts for good reasons just as she does what she thinks she shouldn't do, not knowing that they are good reasons. Just like sometimes we are a lot less rational than we think we are, it is also true that sometimes we are a lot more rational than we think we are.

  Nomy Arpaly

  Stupid, Thinking, Decision

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  4 Copy quote

• Moral virtues and intellectual virtues are very different from each other, and moral virtue has to do with motivation, not cognition. Moral virtue requires a human level of intelligence, but it doesn't require that one be an intelligent human.

  Nomy Arpaly

  Motivation, Intelligent, Intellectual

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  4 Copy quote

• I think it's ok to have wishes that conflict with each other - it's irrational to try to make them both come true, but not irrational simply to have them.

  Nomy Arpaly

  Thinking, Wish, Trying

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  4 Copy quote

• For those of us who want to have control over all our mental states, compatibilist substitutes - such as desiring what we desire to desire - will always be like being told, when you desperately want there to be a God, that yes, God exists, as God is simply the good within people.

  Nomy Arpaly

  People, Desire, God Exists

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  4 Copy quote

• Sometimes we deliberate - for example when we plan a long trip or - if we are not math wizards - when we solve long division problems. However, if we deliberated every time we acted we would never get through the day. Most of the time, we act for reasons without deliberation. I am not just talking about cases of simple, habitual action, like brushing your teeth, but also about more sophisticated action.

  Nomy Arpaly

  Math, Simple, Long

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  4 Copy quote

• Virtue is about wanting right and good things, not about being particularly good at thinking.

  Nomy Arpaly

  Thinking, Virtue, Good Things

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  4 Copy quote

• I am an atheist. I don't think there's anything divine. Beautiful, impressive, awe-inspiring - sure, but not divine.

  Nomy Arpaly

  Beautiful, Atheist, Thinking

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  4 Copy quote

• The fact that only humans above a certain age can be morally virtuous, rather than babies or cats, means that that being moral requires some cognitive ability. If virtue is about desires, it is worth remembering that you can't desire some things without being able to conceive of them. Suppose a virtuous person will desire to make people happy and desire to tell the truth. You can't desire to make people happy without having the concept "happy" and you can't desire to be truthful if you don't have have the concept "lie", so a cat or a baby cannot desire these things.

  Nomy Arpaly

  Baby, Lying, Mean

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  4 Copy quote

• A very tall man once asked a question after my talk. Before beginning his question, he explained that the reason he was standing up is not to be intimidating but rather to make eye contact. His question was essentially "are we really interested in moral motives? Isn't it all about action?". I pointed out to him that it was not enough for him to do the right thing - stand up - but he also wanted me to know that he is doing it from the right motive or for the right reason - to make eye contact, rather than to be intimidating. Voila, moral psychology.

  Nomy Arpaly

  Eye, Men, Psychology

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  4 Copy quote

• Suppose a student of mine writes in her exam that "morality is completely relative to culture, so nothing is absolutely right or wrong. Because of that, it is absolutely wrong to be culturally intolerant". This student, if she believes what she writes, believes a contradiction. She ought not to believe the contradiction - it's a basic epistemic norm. This is true even if she can't avoid believing it - no amount of studying will show her the light.

  Nomy Arpaly

  Believe, Writing, Culture

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  4 Copy quote

• When I see two owls and then two more owls and conclude that I see four owls, I am responding to reasons, and it better not be my choice to believe that two plus two always equals four. If I am a rational person, I will have that belief by necessity, whether I wanted to or not. So it's not that strange to discuss responding to reasons out of necessity.

  Nomy Arpaly

  Believe, Choices, Owl

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  4 Copy quote

• People of relatively low intelligence can be morally wonderful if they desire the right and the good (not necessarily under the description "right" or "good"). Their low intelligence sometimes results in their accidentally doing something wrong, but doing something wrong out of low intelligence alone is like stepping on a person's foot because you are (literally) blind or missing a cry for help because you are (literally) deaf. We do not judge the blind or deaf person as morally bad.

  Nomy Arpaly

  People, Judging, Missing

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  4 Copy quote

• A person is praiseworthy for a right action to the extent that her action manifests, and is rationalized by, good will, that is, concern for the right and the good, not necessarily under the description "right" or "good". A person is blameworthy for a wrong action to the extent that her action manifests, and is rationalized by, ill will - concern for the wrong and bad, also de re - or moral indifference - lack or deficiency of good will.

  Nomy Arpaly

  Action, Moral, Indifference

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  4 Copy quote

• "Externality" is a different phenomenon from akrasia and doesn't always come with it. The set of desires and actions from which one feels alienated isn't always the same as the set of desires and actions of which one disapproves. It has been pointed out that you can disapprove of something inside yourself but still experience it as yours ("damn it, here I go again!"). In addition, you can approve of something inside yourself but feel like it's not yours ("when the emergency sirens went off, it was as if someone calmer and more reasonable took over and knew just what to do").

  Nomy Arpaly

  Desire, Different, Action

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  4 Copy quote

• I don't think we are all irrational every time we fail to see through an argument in a book, but suppose it's true about you. You are still more rational than you think you are. You are irrational in a minor way - believing a misguided theory of the nature of rationality - but rational in a major way - you respond well to probabilistic evidence as you go through the day.

  Nomy Arpaly

  Believe, Book, Thinking

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  4 Copy quote

• Sometimes I suspect that there are two prototypes of philosophers who write about humans - I call them "celestials" and "terrestrials", without implying that celestials have their heads in the clouds or that terrestrials have theirs buried in the ground. The difference between these two types is not so much in their theories but in whether or not they would find it a very sad thing if it turned out that the only way a human is superior to a wolf is this: the human brain is significantly more capacious and complex.

  Nomy Arpaly

  Writing, Brain, Philosopher

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  4 Copy quote

• I think that if your tenure case depends on your proving what you thought was a mathematical theorem and the proposed theorem turns out to be false just before your tenure decision, and you want to get tenure very badly, there is a sense in which it's perfectly understandable and reasonable of you to wish the proposed theorem were true and provable, even if it's logically impossible for it to be.

  Nomy Arpaly

  Thinking, Decision, Wish

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  6 Copy quote

• I am not committed in any way to the traditional concept of character - the concept of "character trait" as involving predictable behavior. I am committed to a view in the neighborhood - the view that the moral worth of one's actions depends on the quality of will expressed in them.

  Nomy Arpaly

  Character, Quality, Action

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  4 Copy quote

• Suppose whether or not someone tells me a lie depends only on whether he wants to, but he is morally indifferent, he doesn't care much about the truth or about me, and his self interest, which he worships, tells him to lie, and so it comes about that given his psychology, it is a forgone conclusion that he will lie to me. I think in this case he is still blameworthy, and that implies, among other things, that he did something he ought not do.

  Nomy Arpaly

  Lying, Thinking, Psychology

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  4 Copy quote

• Duties concern things that are voluntary. I do think that if you have a moral duty to bring me back the book you borrowed, that implies, roughly, that your doing so depends on your wanting to do so: if you want to bring me the book, you will. This is not the case if you are stuck at some airport due to a snowstorm, far away from me. This, however, is not the same as "ought" implying a metaphysical "can".

  Nomy Arpaly

  Book, Thinking, Moral

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  4 Copy quote

• Though we think intrinsic desires tend to be pretty stable, we do not think they imply anything like the amount of predictability in behavior that traditional virtue ethics requires for someone to have a one-word-in-English character trait such as "benevolence". Other things being equal, a person with more of a desire for other people's wellbeing will do more for other people's wellbeing, but things are almost never equal.

  Nomy Arpaly

  Character, Thinking, Desire

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  5 Copy quote

• Incompatibilists will tell you that a work of art has no meaning unless the artists could have chosen to create a different one, but actual artists often say things like "the book chose me" - that is, the work had to be. Some philosophers would call it "volitional necessity", and a similar case that's discussed is the case of Luther saying "here I stand, I can do no other".

  Nomy Arpaly

  Art, Book, Different

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  4 Copy quote

• If I am told my loving you had to happen because of some Freudian stuff about my childhood, that might be degrading or deflationary, but if I am told it had to happen because you are such a wonderful person that I couldn't possibly resist your charms, or because we are so incredibly compatible, then necessity seems very romantic.

  Nomy Arpaly

  Childhood, Loving You, Wonderful

  Source: www.3ammagazine.com

  4 Copy quote

You May Also Like:

T. M. Scanlon